Hi,
I have found the origin of various crashes in the Squeak VM, which is related to the JPEGReadWriter2Plugin. The hunt begun with Juan's Cuis 4.0 release, see the emails exchanged below and the description.
I have attached the fixed C source, but the fix should go in the VM sources, because the code is generated as I see. Please include the fix in the VM sources.
Regards, Andras Pahi
----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: Páhi András Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 9:26 PM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Wow Páhi! This is great! Please send all this to the vm-dev mail list, and ask for it to be included (or directions to do it yourself).
It is my bug in the end... I wrote JPEGReadWriter2Plugin about 10 years ago...
Cheers,
Juan Vuletich
Quoting Páhi András pahia@t-online.hu:
Hi,
Replace the winbuild/src/JPEGReadWriter2Plugin/JPEGReadWriter2Plugin.c file with the attached file, recompile the Squeak VM and Cuis 4.0 rocks. In the plugin there was a 1 off access in the formBits array. Because the code is generated, it needs to be corrected in the VM sources.
How can I got there ?
Executing several times World buildMagnifiedBackgroundImage in Cuis 3.3 crashed the Squeak VM. I exported the background image data, converted from JPEG to other format (BMP/PNG) and set the new format image to World backgroundImageData:. Everything worked as expected. I replaced the formBits array accesses in JPEGReadWriter2Plugin2.c with my routines, checking the indices and reporting off-array access attempts. Then I fixed the places in the C source.
Regards, Andras Pahi ----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: Páhi András Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 12:47 PM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Great. Thanks. You might ask for help or directions in the vm-dev mail list. I'm sure that several people are at least aware of the bug.
Cheers,
Juan Vuletich
Quoting Páhi András pahia@t-online.hu:
Hi, Thank you for your reply. I will dig into the issues with the Windows VM. Regards, Andras Pahi ----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: Páhi András Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 11:59 AM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Hi Páhi,
There is some problem with that Windows VM, not limited to Cuis. If you google "Squeak VM 4.1.1 windows crash" you'll find many results, for example http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7585 http://bugs.squeak.org/bug_view_advanced_page.php?bug_id=7686 and http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7523 .
I'm not involved in the development of the Windows VM, all I can do is recommend using Cog until this is fixed somehow.
Regards,
Juan Vuletich
Quoting Páhi András pahia@t-online.hu:
Hi, I have just gave a shoot on Cuis 4.0 using SqueakVM 4.1.1 on Windows. It even does not start, the crash dump is attached, but with the latest Cog VM it runs fine. I checked the older Cuis 3.3 image with the same SqueakVM, it runs fine. Regards, Andras Pahi
Cheers, Juan Vuletich
P?hi,
Excellent! Thank you very much.
I put this on Mantis also: http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7691
The fix is for the Slang in VMMaker, so we will need to apply it there. I'll look into it over the weekend if nobody has gotten to it sooner :)
Bravo for fixing an old and serious bug!
Dave
On Fri, Apr 27, 2012 at 10:02:43AM +0200, P?hi Andr?s wrote:
Hi,
I have found the origin of various crashes in the Squeak VM, which is related to the JPEGReadWriter2Plugin. The hunt begun with Juan's Cuis 4.0 release, see the emails exchanged below and the description.
I have attached the fixed C source, but the fix should go in the VM sources, because the code is generated as I see. Please include the fix in the VM sources.
Regards, Andras Pahi
----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 9:26 PM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Wow P?hi! This is great! Please send all this to the vm-dev mail list, and ask for it to be included (or directions to do it yourself).
It is my bug in the end... I wrote JPEGReadWriter2Plugin about 10 years ago...
Cheers,
Juan Vuletich
Quoting P?hi Andr?s pahia@t-online.hu:
Hi,
Replace the winbuild/src/JPEGReadWriter2Plugin/JPEGReadWriter2Plugin.c file with the attached file, recompile the Squeak VM and Cuis 4.0 rocks. In the plugin there was a 1 off access in the formBits array. Because the code is generated, it needs to be corrected in the VM sources.
How can I got there ?
Executing several times World buildMagnifiedBackgroundImage in Cuis 3.3 crashed the Squeak VM. I exported the background image data, converted from JPEG to other format (BMP/PNG) and set the new format image to World backgroundImageData:. Everything worked as expected. I replaced the formBits array accesses in JPEGReadWriter2Plugin2.c with my routines, checking the indices and reporting off-array access attempts. Then I fixed the places in the C source.
Regards, Andras Pahi ----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 12:47 PM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Great. Thanks. You might ask for help or directions in the vm-dev mail list. I'm sure that several people are at least aware of the bug. Cheers, Juan Vuletich Quoting P?hi Andr?s <pahia@t-online.hu>: Hi, Thank you for your reply. I will dig into the issues with the Windows VM. Regards, Andras Pahi ----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 11:59 AM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup Hi P?hi, There is some problem with that Windows VM, not limited to Cuis. If you google "Squeak VM 4.1.1 windows crash" you'll find many results, for example http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7585 http://bugs.squeak.org/bug_view_advanced_page.php?bug_id=7686 and http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7523 . I'm not involved in the development of the Windows VM, all I can do is recommend using Cog until this is fixed somehow. Regards, Juan Vuletich Quoting P?hi Andr?s <pahia@t-online.hu>: Hi, I have just gave a shoot on Cuis 4.0 using SqueakVM 4.1.1 on Windows. It even does not start, the crash dump is attached, but with the latest Cog VM it runs fine. I checked the older Cuis 3.3 image with the same SqueakVM, it runs fine. Regards, Andras PahiCheers, Juan Vuletich
This bug was fixed by John McIntosh and added to VMMaker trunk in VMMaker-dtl.192 (9 October 2010). John's fix needs to be merged back into the oscog branch for the Cog VMs. Currently this issue affects interpreter VMs built prior to October 2010, and all current Cog VMs.
Details at http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7691
P?hi,
Thank you for tracking this problem down. If you would like to see the Smalltalk source code that corresponds to your fix, try loading VMMaker (from source.squeak.org). In that package you will find class JPEGReadWriter2Plugin. This is the class that is translated into the C code module that you fixed. There are four lines of code that you changed in the JPEGReadWriter2Plugin2.c module, and these in the methods #primJPEGWriteImage:onByteArray:form:quality:progressiveJPEG:errorMgr: and #primJPEGReadImage:fromByteArray:onForm:doDithering:errorMgr: which are the Smalltalk methods that are translated into the C function primJPEGReadImagefromByteArrayonFormdoDitheringerrorMgr() and primJPEGWriteImageonByteArrayformqualityprogressiveJPEGerrorMgr().
In this case, the source code is actually C code embedded in the Smalltalk method, but the patch still needs to be applied here because the C module is alway generated from the Smalltalk, and a patch to the generated C module would be overwritten whenever the code is regenerated.
Thanks for reporting this!
Dave
On Fri, Apr 27, 2012 at 08:32:35AM -0400, David T. Lewis wrote:
P?hi,
Excellent! Thank you very much.
I put this on Mantis also: http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7691
The fix is for the Slang in VMMaker, so we will need to apply it there. I'll look into it over the weekend if nobody has gotten to it sooner :)
Bravo for fixing an old and serious bug!
Dave
On Fri, Apr 27, 2012 at 10:02:43AM +0200, P?hi Andr?s wrote:
Hi,
I have found the origin of various crashes in the Squeak VM, which is related to the JPEGReadWriter2Plugin. The hunt begun with Juan's Cuis 4.0 release, see the emails exchanged below and the description.
I have attached the fixed C source, but the fix should go in the VM sources, because the code is generated as I see. Please include the fix in the VM sources.
Regards, Andras Pahi
----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 9:26 PM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Wow P?hi! This is great! Please send all this to the vm-dev mail list, and ask for it to be included (or directions to do it yourself).
It is my bug in the end... I wrote JPEGReadWriter2Plugin about 10 years ago...
Cheers,
Juan Vuletich
Quoting P?hi Andr?s pahia@t-online.hu:
Hi,
Replace the winbuild/src/JPEGReadWriter2Plugin/JPEGReadWriter2Plugin.c file with the attached file, recompile the Squeak VM and Cuis 4.0 rocks. In the plugin there was a 1 off access in the formBits array. Because the code is generated, it needs to be corrected in the VM sources.
How can I got there ?
Executing several times World buildMagnifiedBackgroundImage in Cuis 3.3 crashed the Squeak VM. I exported the background image data, converted from JPEG to other format (BMP/PNG) and set the new format image to World backgroundImageData:. Everything worked as expected. I replaced the formBits array accesses in JPEGReadWriter2Plugin2.c with my routines, checking the indices and reporting off-array access attempts. Then I fixed the places in the C source.
Regards, Andras Pahi ----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 12:47 PM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Great. Thanks. You might ask for help or directions in the vm-dev mail list. I'm sure that several people are at least aware of the bug. Cheers, Juan Vuletich Quoting P?hi Andr?s <pahia@t-online.hu>: Hi, Thank you for your reply. I will dig into the issues with the Windows VM. Regards, Andras Pahi ----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 11:59 AM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup Hi P?hi, There is some problem with that Windows VM, not limited to Cuis. If you google "Squeak VM 4.1.1 windows crash" you'll find many results, for example http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7585 http://bugs.squeak.org/bug_view_advanced_page.php?bug_id=7686 and http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7523 . I'm not involved in the development of the Windows VM, all I can do is recommend using Cog until this is fixed somehow. Regards, Juan Vuletich Quoting P?hi Andr?s <pahia@t-online.hu>: Hi, I have just gave a shoot on Cuis 4.0 using SqueakVM 4.1.1 on Windows. It even does not start, the crash dump is attached, but with the latest Cog VM it runs fine. I checked the older Cuis 3.3 image with the same SqueakVM, it runs fine. Regards, Andras PahiCheers, Juan Vuletich
On Sat, Apr 28, 2012 at 3:02 AM, David T. Lewis lewis@mail.msen.com wrote:
This bug was fixed by John McIntosh and added to VMMaker trunk in VMMaker-dtl.192 (9 October 2010). John's fix needs to be merged back into the oscog branch for the Cog VMs. Currently this issue affects interpreter VMs built prior to October 2010, and all current Cog VMs.
Details at http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7691
P?hi,
Thank you for tracking this problem down. If you would like to see the Smalltalk source code that corresponds to your fix, try loading VMMaker (from source.squeak.org). In that package you will find class JPEGReadWriter2Plugin. This is the class that is translated into the C code module that you fixed. There are four lines of code that you changed in the JPEGReadWriter2Plugin2.c module, and these in the methods #primJPEGWriteImage:onByteArray:form:quality:progressiveJPEG:errorMgr: and #primJPEGReadImage:fromByteArray:onForm:doDithering:errorMgr: which are the Smalltalk methods that are translated into the C function primJPEGReadImagefromByteArrayonFormdoDitheringerrorMgr() and primJPEGWriteImageonByteArrayformqualityprogressiveJPEGerrorMgr().
In this case, the source code is actually C code embedded in the Smalltalk method, but the patch still needs to be applied here because the C module is alway generated from the Smalltalk, and a patch to the generated C module would be overwritten whenever the code is regenerated.
Thanks for reporting this!
Hi Dave. Thanks for tacking care. Do you know how to integrate this into Cog branch?
do you have a changeset or what was actually changed ?
thanks
Dave
On Fri, Apr 27, 2012 at 08:32:35AM -0400, David T. Lewis wrote:
P?hi,
Excellent! Thank you very much.
I put this on Mantis also: http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7691
The fix is for the Slang in VMMaker, so we will need to apply it there. I'll look into it over the weekend if nobody has gotten to it sooner :)
Bravo for fixing an old and serious bug!
Dave
On Fri, Apr 27, 2012 at 10:02:43AM +0200, P?hi Andr?s wrote:
Hi,
I have found the origin of various crashes in the Squeak VM, which is
related to the JPEGReadWriter2Plugin.
The hunt begun with Juan's Cuis 4.0 release, see the emails exchanged
below and the description.
I have attached the fixed C source, but the fix should go in the VM
sources, because the code is
generated as I see. Please include the fix in the VM sources.
Regards, Andras Pahi
----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 9:26 PM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Wow P?hi! This is great! Please send all this to the vm-dev mail list,
and ask for it to be included (or directions to do it yourself).
It is my bug in the end... I wrote JPEGReadWriter2Plugin about 10
years ago...
Cheers,
Juan Vuletich
Quoting P?hi Andr?s pahia@t-online.hu:
Hi,
Replace the
winbuild/src/JPEGReadWriter2Plugin/JPEGReadWriter2Plugin.c file with the attached file,
recompile the Squeak VM and Cuis 4.0 rocks. In the plugin there was
a 1 off access in the formBits array.
Because the code is generated, it needs to be corrected in the VM
sources.
How can I got there ?
Executing several times World buildMagnifiedBackgroundImage in Cuis
3.3 crashed the Squeak VM.
I exported the background image data, converted from JPEG to other
format (BMP/PNG) and set the new
format image to World backgroundImageData:. Everything worked as
expected.
I replaced the formBits array accesses in JPEGReadWriter2Plugin2.c
with my routines, checking the indices
and reporting off-array access attempts. Then I fixed the places in
the C source.
Regards, Andras Pahi ----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 12:47 PM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Great. Thanks. You might ask for help or directions in the vm-devmail list. I'm sure that several people are at least aware of the bug.
Cheers, Juan Vuletich Quoting P?hi Andr?s <pahia@t-online.hu>: Hi, Thank you for your reply. I will dig into the issues with theWindows VM.
Regards, Andras Pahi ----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 11:59 AM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup Hi P?hi, There is some problem with that Windows VM, not limited toCuis. If you google "Squeak VM 4.1.1 windows crash" you'll find many results, for example http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7585 http://bugs.squeak.org/bug_view_advanced_page.php?bug_id=7686 and http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7523 .
I'm not involved in the development of the Windows VM, all Ican do is recommend using Cog until this is fixed somehow.
Regards, Juan Vuletich Quoting P?hi Andr?s <pahia@t-online.hu>: Hi, I have just gave a shoot on Cuis 4.0 using SqueakVM 4.1.1 onWindows.
It even does not start, the crash dump is attached, but withthe latest
Cog VM it runs fine. I checked the older Cuis 3.3 image with the same SqueakVM,it runs fine.
Regards, Andras PahiCheers, Juan Vuletich
On Wed, May 2, 2012 at 9:50 AM, Mariano Martinez Peck <marianopeck@gmail.com
wrote:
On Sat, Apr 28, 2012 at 3:02 AM, David T. Lewis lewis@mail.msen.comwrote:
This bug was fixed by John McIntosh and added to VMMaker trunk in VMMaker-dtl.192 (9 October 2010). John's fix needs to be merged back into the oscog branch for the Cog VMs. Currently this issue affects interpreter VMs built prior to October 2010, and all current Cog VMs.
Details at http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7691
P?hi,
Thank you for tracking this problem down. If you would like to see the Smalltalk source code that corresponds to your fix, try loading VMMaker (from source.squeak.org). In that package you will find class JPEGReadWriter2Plugin. This is the class that is translated into the C code module that you fixed. There are four lines of code that you changed in the JPEGReadWriter2Plugin2.c module, and these in the methods #primJPEGWriteImage:onByteArray:form:quality:progressiveJPEG:errorMgr: and #primJPEGReadImage:fromByteArray:onForm:doDithering:errorMgr: which are the Smalltalk methods that are translated into the C function primJPEGReadImagefromByteArrayonFormdoDitheringerrorMgr() and primJPEGWriteImageonByteArrayformqualityprogressiveJPEGerrorMgr().
In this case, the source code is actually C code embedded in the Smalltalk method, but the patch still needs to be applied here because the C module is alway generated from the Smalltalk, and a patch to the generated C module would be overwritten whenever the code is regenerated.
Thanks for reporting this!
Hi Dave. Thanks for tacking care. Do you know how to integrate this into Cog branch?
I do :) I'll do it at my next check-in, which should be in a couple of days.
do you have a changeset or what was actually changed ?
thanks
Dave
On Fri, Apr 27, 2012 at 08:32:35AM -0400, David T. Lewis wrote:
P?hi,
Excellent! Thank you very much.
I put this on Mantis also: http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7691
The fix is for the Slang in VMMaker, so we will need to apply it there. I'll look into it over the weekend if nobody has gotten to it sooner :)
Bravo for fixing an old and serious bug!
Dave
On Fri, Apr 27, 2012 at 10:02:43AM +0200, P?hi Andr?s wrote:
Hi,
I have found the origin of various crashes in the Squeak VM, which is
related to the JPEGReadWriter2Plugin.
The hunt begun with Juan's Cuis 4.0 release, see the emails exchanged
below and the description.
I have attached the fixed C source, but the fix should go in the VM
sources, because the code is
generated as I see. Please include the fix in the VM sources.
Regards, Andras Pahi
----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 9:26 PM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Wow P?hi! This is great! Please send all this to the vm-dev mail
list, and ask for it to be included (or directions to do it yourself).
It is my bug in the end... I wrote JPEGReadWriter2Plugin about 10
years ago...
Cheers,
Juan Vuletich
Quoting P?hi Andr?s pahia@t-online.hu:
Hi,
Replace the
winbuild/src/JPEGReadWriter2Plugin/JPEGReadWriter2Plugin.c file with the attached file,
recompile the Squeak VM and Cuis 4.0 rocks. In the plugin there was
a 1 off access in the formBits array.
Because the code is generated, it needs to be corrected in the VM
sources.
How can I got there ?
Executing several times World buildMagnifiedBackgroundImage in Cuis
3.3 crashed the Squeak VM.
I exported the background image data, converted from JPEG to other
format (BMP/PNG) and set the new
format image to World backgroundImageData:. Everything worked as
expected.
I replaced the formBits array accesses in JPEGReadWriter2Plugin2.c
with my routines, checking the indices
and reporting off-array access attempts. Then I fixed the places in
the C source.
Regards, Andras Pahi ----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 12:47 PM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup
Great. Thanks. You might ask for help or directions in the vm-devmail list. I'm sure that several people are at least aware of the bug.
Cheers, Juan Vuletich Quoting P?hi Andr?s <pahia@t-online.hu>: Hi, Thank you for your reply. I will dig into the issues with theWindows VM.
Regards, Andras Pahi ----- Original Message ----- From: Juan Vuletich (mail lists) To: P?hi Andr?s Sent: Thursday, April 26, 2012 11:59 AM Subject: Re: Cuis 4.0 crash on startup Hi P?hi, There is some problem with that Windows VM, not limited toCuis. If you google "Squeak VM 4.1.1 windows crash" you'll find many results, for example http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7585 http://bugs.squeak.org/bug_view_advanced_page.php?bug_id=7686 and http://bugs.squeak.org/view.php?id=7523 .
I'm not involved in the development of the Windows VM, all Ican do is recommend using Cog until this is fixed somehow.
Regards, Juan Vuletich Quoting P?hi Andr?s <pahia@t-online.hu>: Hi, I have just gave a shoot on Cuis 4.0 using SqueakVM 4.1.1on Windows.
It even does not start, the crash dump is attached, butwith the latest
Cog VM it runs fine. I checked the older Cuis 3.3 image with the same SqueakVM,it runs fine.
Regards, Andras PahiCheers, Juan Vuletich
-- Mariano http://marianopeck.wordpress.com
Thank you to track the origins of the problem. The current Win32 interpreter VM (version 4.1.1) is generated before October 2010. Could you update the Win32 interpreter sources and/or the Win32 interpreter binaries on squeakvm.org ?
Thanks, Andras Pahi
vm-dev@lists.squeakfoundation.org
-
David T. Lewis -
Eliot Miranda -
Mariano Martinez Peck -
Páhi András